I’ve been deeply immersed in an excellent history book, Stalin’s War by Sean McMeekin, 2021. It is at least partially revisionist, and not overtly anti-Hitler and does not often engage in reduction ad Hitlerium (reducing everything to the evil of Hitler, including Hitler himself). It does still believe in the holocaust, a glaring error that usually makes me dismiss a book in disgust (my own
Hi Karl I recently found your substack and it looks like a treasure trove of great information. I am interested in finding clarity on the origins of the Talmud. Have you written extensively on this or do you know where I can find the timeline of its creation and whether the Pharisees in Jesus’ time were involved in it’s creation?
I have researched Talmud origins only to a limited extent and am not an expert. I would think Adam Green at Know More News and his various free speech outlets such as Bitchute etc. would have the answer. In book form, Michael Hoffman's Judaism's Strange Gods will tell you what you need to know. On page 62 begins a summary of all the written Judaic texts, starting with the Mishnah, which says: "The formative writings of Judaism founded on the Oral Law of the first century A.D. Pharisees which Jesus confronted in his lifetime." But Pharisees is not in the index. Hoffman's much larger Judaism Discovered will surely tell everything. The index is loaded for Pharisees, Phariseeism and Pharisaic.
Thank you Karl, and thank you Observer for those links, especially the article by Yitzhak Shichor – bookmarked and downloaded. I have “Stalin’s War” on my bookshelf but have not yet been able to start it (see below).
I do, however, have a dossier of related links and have watched and read most of them but will need to revisit.
Was the interview with author McMeekin that bad? Did he play up the holohoax? I'm finding the book a fascinating summary of otherwise obscured history, such as Balkans, Romania, Baltic states, more on Finland, and above all the sheer revolting and cringe obsequiousness of the US and Roosevelt toward that megalomaniac mass sadist Stalin.
I guess it was my own 'reductio ad holocaustium adsurdum' but as you say, "the book is such excellent honest history otherwise". I will put it back on the priority list. It was also browsing the parent youtube channel and noticing all the standard canard themes.
I'm trying to think of the best single book similar to Stalin's War that is truly revisionist. The Forced War by Hoggan is excellent, but it is pre-war leading up to Sept 1 1939. Hitler's Revolution by Tedor only has a limited coverage of the war years. Germany's War by John Wear has nowhere near the coverage of Stalin's War and much is omitted. I am reluctant to say Hitler's War by Irving for its reductio quality. I would say The Myth of German Villainy is the best source, though it does not much cover Barbarossa, which is the epicenter of WWII.
Perhaps I've mentioned it before on here, but have you read Controversy of Zion by Douglas Reed? It deals with the Jewish problem at large but particularly all the intricacies surrounding WW2 and Zionism at the time. Very insightful.
Yes, I've mentioned in most of my interviews that CoZ was my first entry into the study of the Jewish Issue. It was the first book my mentor offered me, and that was well chosen, at least for me. I was interested to hear that Logos Revealed (Zach) also started his studies with CoZ.
I will bookmark this paper. If the author is Jewish, it makes it harder to dismiss as "antisemitism." Similar to Ilan Pape's book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, or Ron Unz's essay "Holocaust Denial." Or anything by Paul Eisen, Gilad Atzmon, Benjamin Freedman... I write about Not All Jews! in the first chapter of my book Covert Covid Culprits.
One of the best ever posts. Americans are totally oblivious that their government was previously taken over under FDR and again in the COVID-COUP of 2020. Right now Americans have no government. Only 20 members of the House of Representative are not Israel First-China First lackeys and ZERO in the US Senate. Elections are not going to change this. But, hey, the American male leisure class can still go golfing and watch NFL games and have no awareness or concern of what has happened because no one was deprived them of their leisure goods and pursuits or the 401K.
You really think so? I think so, but I don't expect many others to really care today about Communists in the FDR Admin. I'm thinking about offering this to Unz but I don't expect it to get much attention there. Unz is into this kind of history himself, but I wonder if the Unzites will pay much attention.
They seem to be taking a BNW approach rather than a 1984. Sex, entertainment, diversion and hedonist consumerism as the opioids of the masses. It is my approach to try and make revisionist knowledge more interesting, and appeal to a latent perhaps atavistic outrage in the Aryan heart. Our Struggle can be more glorious than a football game.
Hi Karl I recently found your substack and it looks like a treasure trove of great information. I am interested in finding clarity on the origins of the Talmud. Have you written extensively on this or do you know where I can find the timeline of its creation and whether the Pharisees in Jesus’ time were involved in it’s creation?
I'm glad you found us here.
I have researched Talmud origins only to a limited extent and am not an expert. I would think Adam Green at Know More News and his various free speech outlets such as Bitchute etc. would have the answer. In book form, Michael Hoffman's Judaism's Strange Gods will tell you what you need to know. On page 62 begins a summary of all the written Judaic texts, starting with the Mishnah, which says: "The formative writings of Judaism founded on the Oral Law of the first century A.D. Pharisees which Jesus confronted in his lifetime." But Pharisees is not in the index. Hoffman's much larger Judaism Discovered will surely tell everything. The index is loaded for Pharisees, Phariseeism and Pharisaic.
Thank you Karl, and thank you Observer for those links, especially the article by Yitzhak Shichor – bookmarked and downloaded. I have “Stalin’s War” on my bookshelf but have not yet been able to start it (see below).
I do, however, have a dossier of related links and have watched and read most of them but will need to revisit.
Paul Craig Roberts chips in …
• World War II Was Stalin’s War
https://www.sgtreport.com/2021/06/world-war-ii-was-stalins-war/
From John Wear:
• Review of “Stalin’s War: A New History of World War II” Part One
http://www.wearswar.com/2022/05/13/review-of-stalins-war-a-new-history-of-world-war-ii/
This includes a link to the following interview which I thumbed down and it deterred me from prioritising reading the book
• Stalin's War: A New History of World War II with Author Sean McMeekin, PhD - The National WWII Museum
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RLVwB23c1o
• Review of Sean McMeekin’s Book “Stalin’s War: A New History of World War II” Part Two
http://www.wearswar.com/2022/06/02/review-of-sean-mcmeekins-book-stalins-war-a-new-history-of-world-war-ii-part-two/
And for balance here is the latest ‘Snopesy/Wiki-type’ hit job
• Review of Sean McMeekin's Stalin's War - Geoffrey Roberts
https://www.academia.edu/83773835/Review_of_Sean_McMeekins_Stalins_War?email_work_card=view-paper
I read the John Wear review. Not a word about Jews.
Was the interview with author McMeekin that bad? Did he play up the holohoax? I'm finding the book a fascinating summary of otherwise obscured history, such as Balkans, Romania, Baltic states, more on Finland, and above all the sheer revolting and cringe obsequiousness of the US and Roosevelt toward that megalomaniac mass sadist Stalin.
I guess it was my own 'reductio ad holocaustium adsurdum' but as you say, "the book is such excellent honest history otherwise". I will put it back on the priority list. It was also browsing the parent youtube channel and noticing all the standard canard themes.
I'm trying to think of the best single book similar to Stalin's War that is truly revisionist. The Forced War by Hoggan is excellent, but it is pre-war leading up to Sept 1 1939. Hitler's Revolution by Tedor only has a limited coverage of the war years. Germany's War by John Wear has nowhere near the coverage of Stalin's War and much is omitted. I am reluctant to say Hitler's War by Irving for its reductio quality. I would say The Myth of German Villainy is the best source, though it does not much cover Barbarossa, which is the epicenter of WWII.
Silvermaster ~ Goldsmith
Good stuff.
Perhaps I've mentioned it before on here, but have you read Controversy of Zion by Douglas Reed? It deals with the Jewish problem at large but particularly all the intricacies surrounding WW2 and Zionism at the time. Very insightful.
https://www.controversyofzion.info/Controversybook/index.htm
https://archive.org/details/douglas-reed-the-controversy-of-zion/Douglas%20Reed%20-%20The%20Controversy%20of%20Zion%20%28fullsize%29/
As for Chinese communism and the influence of jews, I can recommend the following paper:
Combining Contradictions:
Jewish Contributions to the Chinese Revolution
https://ics.um.edu.my/img/files/IJCS-112-1Yitzhak-for-website.pdf
It's hard to come across (solid) information about this subject so I find it very valuable. It's written by an Israeli academic.
Thank you.
Yes, I've mentioned in most of my interviews that CoZ was my first entry into the study of the Jewish Issue. It was the first book my mentor offered me, and that was well chosen, at least for me. I was interested to hear that Logos Revealed (Zach) also started his studies with CoZ.
https://therealistreport.com/the-realist-report-zach-from-logos-revealed/
I will bookmark this paper. If the author is Jewish, it makes it harder to dismiss as "antisemitism." Similar to Ilan Pape's book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, or Ron Unz's essay "Holocaust Denial." Or anything by Paul Eisen, Gilad Atzmon, Benjamin Freedman... I write about Not All Jews! in the first chapter of my book Covert Covid Culprits.
https://barnesreview.org/product/covert-covid-culprits-an-inquest-chronicle/
Most of what I've seen on the Jews and Mao are meme-level posters and such. This essay should be great knowledge and a solid reference.
Thanks for sharing. Shall check out.
One of the best ever posts. Americans are totally oblivious that their government was previously taken over under FDR and again in the COVID-COUP of 2020. Right now Americans have no government. Only 20 members of the House of Representative are not Israel First-China First lackeys and ZERO in the US Senate. Elections are not going to change this. But, hey, the American male leisure class can still go golfing and watch NFL games and have no awareness or concern of what has happened because no one was deprived them of their leisure goods and pursuits or the 401K.
You really think so? I think so, but I don't expect many others to really care today about Communists in the FDR Admin. I'm thinking about offering this to Unz but I don't expect it to get much attention there. Unz is into this kind of history himself, but I wonder if the Unzites will pay much attention.
They seem to be taking a BNW approach rather than a 1984. Sex, entertainment, diversion and hedonist consumerism as the opioids of the masses. It is my approach to try and make revisionist knowledge more interesting, and appeal to a latent perhaps atavistic outrage in the Aryan heart. Our Struggle can be more glorious than a football game.